Menu of MDI Lobster & BBQ in Southwest Harbor, Maine, USA

Menu Overview

Located on the picturesque Clark Point Road in Southwest Harbor, Maine, MDI Lobster & BBQ delivers a masterclass in blending fresh seafood with smoky, tender barbecue—an intersection that captures the essence of coastal New England dining. The menu is a curated journey through classic Maine flavors, elevated by expert preparation and thoughtful hospitality.

The standout dish, the Lobster and Ribs Combo, exemplifies the best of both worlds. The lobster arrives fresh, flaky, and sweet, kissed with just enough buttery richness—extra butter is always available for those who want to amplify that lusciousness. The ribs, on the other hand, are fall-off-the-bone tender, imbued with a Thai BBQ special sauce that adds a delightful fusion twist. Paired with perfectly seasoned green beans and savory beans loaded with smoky meat, the sides complement the mains without overpowering them.

For those craving a seafood classic, the Justin Lobster Roll shines bright. Crafted with garlic aioli, it’s a neat balance of creamy and fresh, nestled in a buttery, toasted bun—the kind of roll that beckons you back. The fried haddock sandwich, a must-try for fish lovers, comes served with crisp fries, though it would be nice if there were more side options. Still, the haddock’s golden crust and succulent interior speak to precise frying techniques and quality sourcing.

Barbecue fans are well catered to with hearty offerings like smoked brisket and pulled pork family meals, perfect for sharing. The dry rub cauliflower and street corn provide solid vegetarian options, highlighting the kitchen’s attention to variety and flavor without losing focus on the core seafood and BBQ strengths. The pork empanadas are flavorful but may benefit from a crisper, fully cooked dough—a minor flaw in an otherwise tightly composed menu.

Service and ambiance here elevate the experience beyond just food. Diners can enjoy their meals either under a spacious tent or at tables overlooking the harbor’s serene waters—scenic enough to enhance any meal. Staff are consistently praised for their warmth and attentiveness; the owner’s personal touch of greeting tables and ensuring satisfaction creates a genuine sense of community.

Frequent patrons like Andrew Felker and Justin Tabatabai recount memorable meals filled with clam chowder, whole bellied clams, and the eagerly sought-after ribs. The willingness of the team to address issues swiftly—for example, reheating pulled pork or ensuring availability of BBQ—reflects deep commitment to customer satisfaction. This responsiveness, combined with fresh, quality ingredients and balanced preparations, makes MDI Lobster & BBQ a standout for families, couples, and solo travelers alike.

In summary, MDI Lobster & BBQ is more than a seafood restaurant; it’s a destination that respects Maine’s culinary heritage while innovating with thoughtful flavors and attentive service. Whether you come for the lobster, ribs, or a comforting seafood sandwich, expect a meal that’s rich in taste, atmosphere, and heart.